A federal appeals court panel has declined to grant the Justice Department's emergency request for an immediate order demanding California segregate approximately 20,000 mail-in ballots. The Trump administration claims these ballots were sent to individuals it alleges are likely non-citizens.

The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals panel issued a 2-1 ruling on Monday, stating that the court currently lacks jurisdiction to intervene in the matter. The decision effectively sends the case back to the district court, where a hearing on the Justice Department's lawsuit is already scheduled for Tuesday afternoon.

Circuit Judge Mark Bennett and Circuit Judge Gabriel Sanchez, appointed by Presidents Donald Trump and Joe Biden respectively, were in the majority. They wrote that "The United States’s claimed emergency, at least in part, is a self-constructed one." They attributed part of the delay to the U.S. itself, including its "own delay in filing suit, in realizing that existing California state law governs the issuance and processing of ballots, in recognizing that California has millions of registered voters and processes ballots on a schedule aligned with that scale, and in communicating to the court its desired relief."

The Justice Department had filed suit against California earlier in October, alleging the state failed to adequately review a list of individuals the Trump administration identified as potential non-citizens who had received mail-in ballots for the upcoming midterm election. Los Angeles officials, in court filings, stated that a preliminary analysis of 200 names from the list revealed a significant percentage of individuals who identified as U.S. born, and many others with no voting history.

During a rare Sunday emergency hearing, the appeals court panel expressed considerable skepticism regarding the Justice Department's request for swift intervention. Circuit Judge Bennett repeatedly questioned the court's jurisdiction to step in at this stage, given that a district court hearing was already calendared. He also raised constitutional concerns about the lawsuit itself.

Circuit Judge Patrick Bumatay, appointed by President Trump, dissented from the majority opinion. The Justice Department's legal strategy has faced scrutiny regarding its timing and the basis for seeking an emergency appeal when a lower court hearing was imminent.

Officials in Los Angeles indicated that out of 200 names analyzed, nearly 40% provided evidence of U.S. birth, suggesting citizenship. Furthermore, 71.2% of these records showed no prior voting history, according to court documents.

The appeals court's decision means the district court will proceed with its scheduled hearing, where arguments will be made regarding the Justice Department's lawsuit and its request for action concerning the mail-in ballots.